5 Mistakes Homeowners Make When Hiring a Tile Installer
Mistakes Hiring a Tile Installer are more common than you might think – and they can end up costing you time, money, and even your dream bathroom. Many homeowners in Minneapolis and St. Paul make simple missteps when selecting a contractor for a bathroom remodeling project or new tile shower, leading to delays and expensive tile repair down the road. However, by understanding the common pitfalls, you can avoid these tile contractor mistakes and ensure your project goes smoothly. Below are 5 mistakes homeowners make when hiring a bathroom tile installer – and how to avoid them for a successful renovation in the Twin Cities Metro.
Choosing the Cheapest Quote (Price Over Quality)
It’s natural to look for the best deal, but hiring the cheapest tile installer simply based on price is often a costly mistake. A bid that’s significantly lower than others may indicate the contractor is cutting corners – using cheap materials, rushing the job, or lacking experience. Tile installation requires proper subfloor prep, precise layout, and careful finishing. A bargain installer who skips steps can leave you with noticeable tile installation errors like uneven grout lines, loose or hollow tiles, and poor water protection. Moreover, problems might not show immediately but will emerge months later as cracked grout, leaks, or tiles popping up – meaning you’ll pay for repairs or rework anyway. In fact, industry experts caution that a price “too good to be true” often signals the installer isn’t fully qualified .
Why it’s a problem:
The lowest bidder might save you a few bucks now, but shoddy workmanship can lead to costly repairs soon after. For example, improper underlayment or skipped waterproofing could cause water damage behind your walls. Re-doing a failed tile job can easily cost far more than hiring a quality contractor in the first place. You could also face added inconvenience from having to tear out and replace defective work.
How to avoid it:
Get multiple quotes for your tile installation project, but compare more than just the bottom line. Look at what each estimate includes. Does the contractor detail prep work (like cement backer board or leveling)? Do they specify quality materials (thinset, grout sealer, etc.)? A reputable Minneapolis tile contractor will provide a reasonably competitive price along with a thorough scope of work. Ask questions about anything unclear. Remember, an experienced installer with proper methods might charge a bit more, but you’re paying for expertise and a longer-lasting result. It’s better to invest in doing it right the first time than to pay twice.
Be sure you understand exactly what’s included in the quote so you can compare apples to apples between contractors. And if one bid is dramatically lower than the rest, consider it a red flag – they may be omitting essential steps or not fully insured. Ultimately, choose based on value and reputation, not just price. Otherwise, that “cheap” job could end up an expensive lesson (and a call for tile repair later).
Not Checking Credentials (License, Insurance & Experience)
Just because someone advertises as a tile installer doesn’t mean they are qualified or authorized to do the work. One of the biggest mistakes homeowners make is skipping the step of verifying credentials. In Minnesota, contractors who perform residential remodeling or specialized trades must be licensed and insured to protect you as the homeowner. If you hire an unlicensed person or a jack-of-all-trades handyman without proper qualifications, you risk poor quality work and liability issues. If an uninsured worker gets hurt on your property, the claim could fall on your homeowner’s insurance. Similarly, an unlicensed contractor might disappear if problems arise, leaving you with little recourse.
Why it’s a problem:
A lack of credentials often goes hand-in-hand with lack of experience or professionalism. Your bathroom tile project involves critical steps (waterproofing, proper mortars, correct tile cutting, etc.) that trained professionals know how to do. An inexperienced installer may not follow industry standards, leading to failures. Additionally, without a license or contract, it’s harder to enforce warranties or have any legal backing if the job goes wrong. Minnesota requires residential remodeling contractors to carry a state license – which means they’ve met basic competency and insurance requirements. If you don’t check this, you might unknowingly hire someone who isn’t accountable.
How to avoid it:
Always vet your tile contractor’s credentials. Ask for their Minnesota contractor’s license number and proof of liability insurance. You can verify active licenses online via the Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry’s license lookup to ensure they’re in good standing. Also inquire about specific experience with tile work:
How many years have they been specializing in tile installation (not just general construction)? A dedicated bathroom tile installer will be familiar with local building codes and best practices (for example, knowing how our Twin Cities climate might affect materials). It’s wise to choose a contractor who has demonstrated expertise in bathrooms or tile projects similar to yours. Look for any professional certifications or affiliations, too. Membership in the National Tile Contractors Association (NTCA) or being a Certified Tile Installer (CTI) are signs they stay up-to-date with industry standards. While not every good installer will have those badges, seeing them can give you extra confidence.
Side Tip:
If a contractor is hesitant to provide license or insurance info, or tries to convince you it’s not necessary, walk away. Reputable tile contractors know homeowners need this peace of mind. Hiring a properly credentialed professional means your tile installation will meet building codes and quality standards, giving you a beautiful result that lasts.
Skipping Reviews and References
Another common error is not checking the installer’s reputation before hiring. Even if a tile contractor presents well during an estimate, you need to verify they have a solid track record. Reviews and references give you unfiltered insight into what it’s like to work with that person or company. Unfortunately, in the excitement of planning a remodel, some homeowners skip this due diligence. Hiring without researching past customer experiences can be a gamble – you might luck out, or you might end up with a contractor who has a history of no-shows, poor communication, or subpar workmanship.
Why it’s a problem:
A tile installer could have all the right credentials on paper but still deliver a bad customer experience. Maybe they’re chronically late, leave a mess, or fail to finish on schedule. Maybe their quality starts strong but they don’t resolve small issues at the end. By skipping reviews, you miss the chance to catch these red flags. Consistently negative feedback (or no online presence at all) is a warning sign. On the other hand, an installer with dozens of positive reviews and testimonials has demonstrated reliability and quality. Without checking, you’re essentially going in blind.
How to avoid it:
Take some time to research the tile contractor online and offline. Start with a simple search of their business name on Google. Read through Google reviews and see their star rating. Look at what people in Minneapolis or the Twin Cities are saying – do they praise the craftsmanship? Mention the project finished on time and on budget? Also check platforms like Yelp, Angi (Angie’s List), or Houzz for additional homeowner reviews of tile installers. Don’t just rely on one source; cross-reference multiple sites for a well-rounded view.
Additionally, visit the Better Business Bureau (BBB) website and search the company name. The BBB profile will show you if any formal complaints have been filed and how (or if) they were resolved. A strong BBB rating or Accreditation is a plus, but pay attention to any issues noted. If the contractor has a Facebook business page or is active on community forums (like a local Nextdoor group), see what interactions or feedback appear there as well.
Importantly, ask for references from the contractor directly. Speaking to one or two past clients can be invaluable. A good tile installer will readily provide a few references you can contact. When you call those references, ask about their overall satisfaction, whether any problems arose and how they were handled, and if they’d hire the installer again. Sometimes you might even be invited to see the finished work in person, which can be reassuring.
Finally, trust patterns you see: if many people mention the contractor by name with glowing reviews and beautiful photos of completed bathrooms, it’s a great sign. Conversely, if you find multiple complaints about things like “didn’t show up after taking deposit” or “sloppy tile alignment and poor cleanup,” steer clear. Consistency in reviews is key – one odd bad review may happen to anyone, but several indicate a trend.
In short, do your homework on reviews. In the digital age, there’s no reason to go in uninformed. Spending an hour checking references can save you weeks of frustration later. By choosing someone with an excellent reputation for tile installation in the community, you greatly increase the chances your project will be a success. Remember, a tile contractor who is proud of their work will encourage you to check their reviews and past projects – it’s part of how they earn your trust.
Overlooking Waterproofing in Tile Showers and Wet Areas
When it comes to bathrooms, especially tile showers, proper waterproofing is absolutely crucial – yet many homeowners don’t know to ask about it. Overlooking waterproofing or assuming every contractor does it correctly is a mistake that can literally seep through the cracks. Tile, grout, and cement board alone are not waterproof; they’re water-resistant at best. Without a dedicated waterproofing system behind the scenes, moisture can penetrate into your walls or subfloor. Unfortunately, some less-qualified installers might skip steps here (to save time or money), and if you never discuss it, you won’t know until a leak shows up later.
Why it’s a problem:
A shower that isn’t properly waterproofed is a ticking time bomb. Water that sneaks behind tiles can cause mold growth, rot wooden studs or subfloors, and degrade drywall. You might not notice the damage until it’s extensive – perhaps a ceiling stain in the room below or tiles falling off as the wall deteriorates. By then, repairs involve not just redoing the shower, but also fixing structural issues. Minneapolis and St. Paul homeowners also have to consider our climate: in colder months, a lack of waterproofing combined with freezing temps can worsen tile failures (water that gets in and freezes can crack tiles or grout). In short, improper waterproofing can turn your beautiful new bathroom into a nightmare of repairs.
How to avoid it:
Always discuss waterproofing details with your tile contractor. A qualified bathroom tile installer will bring this topic up first, because it’s integral to a lasting job. Make sure your installer plans to use proper waterproofing membranes or materials in all wet areas. This typically includes a moisture barrier behind shower walls (or a waterproof backer board) and a pan liner or liquid membrane for the shower floor and curb. If you’re doing a tub surround or any floor that could get wet, those areas need protection too (like a membrane under the tile or a sealing system).
Don’t hesitate to ask pointed questions, such as:
-
“What waterproofing system do you use for tile showers?” – A pro might mention using a specific product (e.g., a Schluter®-KERDI membrane, RedGard coating, or a GoBoard® waterproof backer). The key is they should have a clear answer.
-
“Do you apply a membrane on the walls and floor, or use cement backer board?” – There are different methods (sheet membranes, liquid-applied, foam boards), but they should at least use one of them in addition to cement board. Simply tiling over greenboard drywall, for example, is not acceptable in a shower.
-
“How will you ensure the shower is fully sealed against leaks?” – Listen for specifics: sealing corners and seams, sloping the shower pan correctly, protecting drain weep holes, etc. A knowledgeable installer will happily explain their process (e.g., “We’ll install a PVC liner under the mortar bed and run it up 6 inches behind the wall tile, plus waterproof all niches and bench areas.”).
By asking these questions, you send a message that you know waterproofing matters. A true professional will take the time to walk you through their waterproofing plan. If someone dismisses these questions or says “Oh, the tile and grout will keep water out,” that’s a huge red flag – thank them and move on to another contractor. As one major tile manufacturer warns, “There’s no cutting corners when it comes to installing shower tile” – even a small oversight in waterproofing can lead to big problems .
For your own peace of mind, it helps to know some basics. For example, shower walls should have either a plastic/poly sheeting behind cement board or a roll-on waterproof membrane on the surface (some installers do both). Shower floors require a properly sloped pan (¼” per foot toward the drain) and a liner or waterproof base; after tiling, the installer should also do a flood test to check for leaks before finishing. If you’re not sure what any of this means, don’t worry – you don’t have to become an expert overnight. The takeaway is to ensure your installer is an expert who doesn’t skip these steps.
Lastly, consider any other wet areas: bathroom floors near a tub or around a toilet can benefit from waterproofing underlayment (especially if it’s a second-floor bathroom where a leak could damage the ceiling below). While not as critical as showers, it’s something to discuss.
By prioritizing waterproofing, you’re safeguarding your investment. A properly waterproofed tile installation might not be visible in the end result, but you’ll definitely see the difference over time – in what doesn’t happen (no leaks, no mold, no callbacks to fix the shower). This is one area where you should insist on quality materials and workmanship. It’s far cheaper to do it right during construction than to rip out a failing shower later. In summary, never assume – explicitly confirm that your tile installer will make your bathroom watertight. Your walls (and future self) will thank you!
Not Getting a Detailed Written Contract
Excitement to start a project can sometimes lead homeowners to shake hands on an agreement without putting it in writing. Proceeding without a written contract or clear scope of work is a serious mistake when hiring a tile installer (or any contractor). Even if you discussed things verbally, memories can differ and misunderstandings can arise. A written contract or at least a detailed estimate forms the blueprint for your project – it ensures both you and the installer are on the same page about what’s expected.
Why it’s a problem:
Without a contract, you have little protection if the contractor doesn’t fulfill all promises. Important details might get overlooked: Which exact tasks are included? Who buys the materials? When will the job start and end? How will payments be handled? If these aren’t documented, you might end up with disputes like “I thought you were going to also replace the baseboards?” or “We never agreed on sealing the grout, so that’ll cost extra.” Verbal agreements are prone to confusion, especially if a contractor conveniently “forgets” something that was said.
Additionally, a contract sets terms for resolving issues – for example, it may outline how corrections are handled or what warranty the installer provides. Without anything in writing, you have no reference if things go off-track. You could also be left vulnerable to unexpected price increases or incomplete work with no clear recourse. In worst-case scenarios, contractors who operate without contracts might also be unlicensed, and they bank on the job staying “off the record.” That’s not a scenario you want to be in when your bathroom is half demoed.
How to avoid it:
Insist on a written agreement before any work begins, even if it’s a relatively small tile job. For a full bathroom remodel or tile installation project, a formal contract is standard. For a simpler repair or single-day job, a detailed written estimate or proposal that you sign off on can suffice. The key is to have everything spelled out. Make sure the document includes at minimum:
Scope of work
-
Exactly what areas will be worked on and what will be done (e.g., “Demolish existing shower tile; install new porcelain tile on shower walls and floor; re-tile bathroom floor; etc.”). This should mention any prep work like removing old tile or repairing subfloor, so it’s clear what’s included.
Materials and labor
-
Who is responsible for supplying the tiles, grout, backer board, etc.? Is the cost of those materials included in the price? It should list specifics (tile allowance or product codes if decided, brand of waterproofing or grout sealer, etc.). Also note if any part of the work will be subcontracted.
Project timeline
-
The expected start date and completion date (or duration of the project). While unforeseen issues can cause changes, you should have an agreed window. This helps avoid a project that drags on indefinitely.
Cost and payment schedule
-
The total cost you will pay, and when payments are due. Typically, a contract might say something like 30% deposit, 50% upon reaching a midway point (after setting tile, for instance), and 20% upon completion and your satisfaction. Avoid paying the full amount upfront. A defined schedule protects both parties – you pay as work progresses, and the contractor has incentive to finish to receive final payment.
Warranty/Guarantee
-
Any warranty on the workmanship should be stated. For example, many quality contractors will offer a guarantee to fix any installation issues (like tiles loosening or leaks) for a year or more. Also, if the manufacturer of the tile or grout provides a warranty, that can be noted. Having it in writing means if a problem surfaces, you have documentation of the promise to fix it.
Everything agreed upon should be documented in writing and signed by you and the contractor. Don’t rely on casual texts or phone chats as your “agreement.” If changes come up during the project – and changes do happen! – get those in writing too (a simple change order form or even an email confirmation of the new work and cost is better than a verbal OK).
A solid contract not only protects you, but it protects the contractor as well by clearly outlining the job. Professionals actually prefer to work with a contract because it sets clear expectations and reduces the chance of misunderstandings. If you encounter a contractor who says “We don’t need to bother with paperwork, I trust you,” consider that a warning sign. Reputable Twin Cities tile installers will typically have a standard contract or proposal ready to go; it’s part of doing business properly.
To sum up, don’t start any tile work without a written plan. It doesn’t need to be ten pages of legalese – a one-page detailed proposal can do the job – but it should cover the who, what, when, and how much. By getting it all in writing, you’ll prevent a lot of potential headaches and ensure your bathroom project stays on track and on budget. This way, when the last tile is grouted and the job is done, both you and your installer know that everything promised was delivered.
Final Thoughts
Hiring the right tile installer in Minneapolis–St. Paul comes down to doing a bit of homework upfront. By avoiding these common mistakes – from chasing the lowest bid to neglecting crucial details like credentials, references, waterproofing, and contracts – you’ll set your project up for success. The reward is a beautifully tiled bathroom or shower that not only looks great but performs great for years to come. When you take the time to choose a qualified professional and communicate clearly, you can enjoy your renovation with peace of mind, knowing you’ve protected your investment. Now that you’re aware of the pitfalls, you’re better equipped to hire a tile installer who will get the job done right the first time, resulting in a bathroom you’ll love and an experience that won’t leave you with regrets.
Hiring a Tile Installer in Minneapolis – FAQ
How can I find a reliable bathroom tile installer in Minneapolis?
Finding a trustworthy installer requires a bit of research. Start by asking friends or neighbors in Minneapolis for recommendations – local word-of-mouth is valuable. Then check online reviews (Google, Yelp, etc.) for bathroom tile installers in the Twin Cities to see who consistently has high ratings. Verify that the contractor is licensed in Minnesota and carries insurance. It also helps to view photos of their past tile work or even visit a recent project if possible. Essentially, look for a tile specialist with a strong local reputation, verified credentials, and plenty of happy customers in the Minneapolis area.
What questions should I ask a tile contractor before hiring?
Ask any prospective tile contractor about their experience and process. Important questions include: “How many years have you been installing tile?”, “Are you licensed and insured?”, and “Have you completed projects similar to mine?”. Inquire about who will perform the work (crew or subcontractors), what materials they recommend, and how they handle prep and waterproofing (especially for showers). It’s also wise to ask for references from past clients and a detailed written estimate. Don’t forget to discuss timeline and warranty – “How long will the project take and do you guarantee your work?”. A professional contractor should answer these questions clearly and patiently. (For more tips, see our in-depth Tile Installation FAQs for guidance on the process.)
How much does it cost to hire a tile installer in the Twin Cities?
The cost to hire a tile installer in the Twin Cities varies widely depending on the scope of your project. For smaller jobs like replacing a few tiles or doing a backsplash, you might pay a few hundred dollars. Larger projects – for example, tiling a full walk-in shower or a complete bathroom floor – can range from a couple thousand to several thousand dollars. Factors include the size of the area, the type of tile (ceramic, porcelain, mosaic, natural stone), the complexity of the pattern, and any extra features (like in-floor heating or custom niches). Labor rates in Minneapolis–St. Paul are generally competitive; you can expect to pay for quality craftsmanship.
Always get a detailed quote from your contractor. This way you’ll see the breakdown of costs and can compare it with other quotes. Remember, the cheapest price isn’t always the best – consider the installer’s experience and reputation as part of the value. Overall, budget for quality work and you’ll be happier in the long run with a tile installation that stands the test of time.
Should I hire a professional or attempt a DIY tile installation?
It depends on the project complexity and your comfort level. DIY tile installation can be rewarding for a small, straightforward project – for instance, installing a simple backsplash or retiling a small floor – especially if you have some handyman experience and the right tools. There are plenty of tutorials available, and working at your own pace can save labor costs. However, for a bathroom remodel or anything involving a shower or tub (with all the waterproofing requirements), hiring a professional is highly recommended. Mistakes in layout or sealing can be very costly to fix and may not show up until later. Professionals bring expertise, from properly preparing surfaces to cutting tiles precisely and using the correct materials for Minnesota’s climate. They will also work faster than most DIYers, with higher quality results.
Many Minneapolis homeowners start a DIY tile project only to discover it’s more challenging than expected – lippage (uneven tiles), messy grout lines, or water leaks are common pitfalls. If you’re on the fence, consider a hybrid approach: hire a pro for the critical areas (like the shower) and maybe DIY an easier section (like a backsplash). Generally, for bathroom tile installations, especially in a primary bathroom or if you want a custom look, a professional installer will ensure a polished, durable outcome. It’s an investment in peace of mind and longevity for your remodel.
Do tile installers need to be licensed in Minnesota?
Yes – in Minnesota, tile installers who operate as contractors (especially for bathroom or general remodeling work) typically must hold a residential contractor or remodeler license. The state requires licensing for any residential building or remodeling work over a certain dollar amount. This means your tile installer should be licensed if they’re doing a significant project like a bathroom renovation (which most tile jobs are). A licensed contractor has met state requirements for knowledge and carries liability insurance, which protects you as a homeowner. Always ask for your tile contractor’s Minnesota license number and verify it.
You can quickly check a license on the Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry’s website to ensure it’s current. Hiring a licensed tile installer gives you an extra layer of security that the work will comply with building codes and professional standards. It’s one of the reasons we suggest checking credentials – it separates the true professionals from the fly-by-night operations. So, to answer the question: yes, make sure the tile installer you hire in Minnesota is properly licensed (and insured) before signing a contract.
Know someone planning a remodel? Help them out — Click on Icons below to share this Blog!
Visit us on Social Media
